Game accounts from The New York Times

(click on date to get account)

Eagles of New York

Gothams of New York

3

21

June 23, 1855

Newarks of New Jersey

Olympics of Brooklyn

31

10

July 18, 1855

Baltics of New York

Unions of Morrisania

17

23

August 2, 1856

Gothams of New York

Eagles of New York

43

20

August 11, 1857

All Star Preparations

 

July 12, 1858

All Stars of New York

All Stars of Brooklyn

22

18

July 21, 1858

Eagles of New York

Knickerbockers of New York

 

Mutuals of New York

Monumentals of New York

45

18

 

71

13

July 30, 1858

All Stars of Brooklyn

All Stars of New York

18

29

September 11, 1858

Excelsiors of Brooklyn

Knickerbockers of New York

26

22

July 1, 1859

Gothams of New York

Eckfords of Brooklyn

10

17

August 15, 1859

Oaklands of Brooklyn

Powhatans of Brooklyn

13

13

August 25, 1859

Excelsiors of Brooklyn

Atlantics of Brooklyn

23

4

July 20, 1860

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Mutuals of New York

34

15

July 31, 1860

Excelsiors of Brooklyn

Putnams of Brooklyn

23

7

August 21, 1860

Mutuals of New York

Atlantics of Brooklyn

 

Baltics of New York

Manhattens of New York

14

26

 

15

25

August 21, 1860

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Harlems of New York

 

Lexingtons of New York

Baltics of New York

28

8

 

23

17

September 4, 1860

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Liberty of New Brunswick

15

10

October 9, 1860

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Eckfords of Brooklyn

17

15

October 17, 1860

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Eckfords of Brooklyn

15

20

October 23, 1860

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Mutuals of New York

 

Gothams of New York

Stars of Brooklyn

15

11

 

19

23

September 12, 1863

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Mutuals of New York

42

18

September 25, 1863

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Eckfords of Brooklyn

15

20

October 23, 1863

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Empires of New York

13

13

July 1, 1864

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Camdens of Philadelphia

64

10

August 10, 1864

Stars of Brooklyn

Enterprise of Brooklyn

47

38

August 7, 1865

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Stars of Brooklyn

16

7

September 6, 1868

Atlantics of Brooklyn

Unions of New York

24

21

August 23, 1870